Wednesday, September 13, 2006

Is his tongue in his cheek?

Every Wednesday NPR's Morning Edition airs a three minute (or so) commentary by Frank Deford. In this morning's airing, Deford decided to jump on the boys-are-lagging-behind bandwagon.
But not really...
...I think.
It was hard to tell.
It went something like this (my interpretation is in {}):
Studies {dubious as they may be} show boys are lagging behind in school at all levels. More women enter college now than men.
Deford claims it is because men, as boys, are pushed towards sport. They are rewarded for success in sport more so than success in the classroom. {Interesting hypothesis. I certainly agree boys are rewarded for playing sport and are very much encouraged to play sports more so than girls.}
This has lead to the decrease in boys in college because girls--who aren't encouraged to play sports--spend time studying because they are not preoccupied with sport and thus get smarter. {Hard to tell at this point whether he is presenting this as a legitimate theory we should consider or if this is the moment we should chuckle to ourselves and say, "Oh, Frank."}
And then he started talking about sport management programs for male athletes (who are not so smart but in college because of their athletic abilities) and how they just produce not so smart people to run athletic programs thus perpetuating the stupidity cycle. {While this is not universally true it does seem there are a lot of male athletes in sport management. But if one really wants a position in athletic administration you will definitely need a master's degree if not a PhD. So the stupid that Deford mentions probably get weeded out along the way. Alas I haven't come across a lot of sport management people--even those with higher degrees--who have a very nuanced understanding of critical issues such as gender and race and class and how they play out in sport. Not because they are bad people but because it seems like sport management degree programs don't really stress these things.}
Then Deford notes how smaller schools are adding football to increase the number of men in the student body. {Yes, happened at a school I used to teach at that had gone co-educational in the last decade. He fails to note however that this usually means Title IX numbers are even more skewed with this addition because the percentage of women in the undergrad population is probably higher than the percentage of women playing sports. Adding more male athletes hurts these numbers even more because their addition to the undergrad population has less impact than their addition to the athletic department population.}
Deford defends Title IX however, telling men to stop fighting it because studies show {again, nothing cited or specific} that female athletes start to become more like male athletes. Their grades fall and they participate less in university activities. {OK I have read something like this but it was from the 80s. And it's interesting that when grades fall and interest wanes this makes one more like a man...what's that about?}
So, Deford concludes that the only way to decrease this widening gap between boys and girls is to get more girls playing sports and thus make them more male-like {not masculine because implicit in that adjective is the issue of physicality which Deford stays far away from here.}

In the end of course we can't really take Deford's "suggestion" seriously. It seems like a big joke on the social scientists that are proclaiming boys are suffering in school. But in the process of making this joke, Deford relies on and perpetuates so many stereotypes of men, women, and athletes that I can't even get to them all here.
So it seems his tongue is indeed somewhere in his cheek. My suggestion: next time he should just bite it.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Hoodia Diet Pills
Hoodia Gordonii
Pure Hoodia
Hoodia Side E ffects
Hoodia Patch
Hoodia Prices
gordonii hoodia plus
south african hoodia
hoodia weight loss pill
hoodia gordonii diet pill
hoodia gordonii cactus
gordonii side effects
pure hoodia gordonii
dex l10 hoodia gordonii
gordonii hoodia plus review
500  gordonii hoodia
hoodia gordonii review
gordonii hoodia rx
african gordonii hoodia
bioptimax gordonii hoodia
hoodia gordonii plant
500 gordonii hoodia
hoodia weight loss
gordonii herb hoodia paradise
african hoodia oprah
diet hoodia gordonii
hoodia gordonii liquid
60 minutes hoodia
effects hoodia plus side
hoodia gordonii succulen
delmar dex  hoodia
500 african complex
hoodia gordonii seed
hoodia gordonii pill
gordonii hoodia oprah
bioptimax gordonii hoodia
diet pill hoodia cactus
hoodia gordonii canada
hoodia gordonii work
buy hoodia gordonii
phytopharm hoodia
hoodia gordonii powder
57 gordonii guide
hoodia gordonii gnc
hoodia gordonii propagation
100 gordonii hoodia pure
desert burn hoodia
hoodia gordonii cactus safe
hoodia gordonii research
hoodia south africa
hoodia gordonii fact
gordonii hoodia patch
10 hoodia gordonii
hoodia gordonii and product
100 hoodia gordonii
500 african gordonii
complex gordonii hoodia
hoodia gordonii danger
buy gordonii hoodia plus
hoodia gordonii information
hoodia gordonii cactus pill
hoodia gordonii uk
hoodia gordonii australia
hoodia plant for sale
hoodia testimonials
100 diet gordonii hoodia
hoodia gordonii capsule
best hoodia gordonii
hoodia cactus powder
hoodia gordonii safe
bulk hoodia gordonii
hoodia gordonii grow
hoodia lose weight
diethoodia supplement
forum gordonii hoodia
dietary hoodia supplement
ebay gordonii hoodia
hoodia gordonii effects
gordonii hoodia in plus uk
hoodia gordonii appetite
gordonii hoodia offshelf
hoodia in metabolic
gordonii succulent plan
gordonii hoodia mg pure
gordonii hoodia product
growing hoodia gordonii
hoodia gordonii natural
hoodoba hoodia gordonii
herb hoodia gordonii
diet gordonii hoodia
diet gordonii hoodia pill
gordonii hoodia tablet
488 gordonii hoodia mg
canada gordonii hoodia
effects hoodia plant side
hoodia cactus plant
gordonii plant for sale
hoodia loss plant weight
hoodia smartburn
hoodia supreme
920 hoodia
diet hoodia patch
hoodia weight loss
hoodia xpf
diet hoodia miracle
hoodia mhpbiotech

hoodia diet pills
hoodia gordonii
pure hoodia
hoodia side effects
hoodia patch
hoodia prices
Daily Health Tips
Natural Bodybuilding
Diet and Nutrition
Self Improvement
Diet Pills
Diet Plans
Vitamins and Supplements
Fitness & Exercise
Weight Loss
Fitness Equipments
Weight loss Diseases
Weight Loss Success Stories
General Health
Women's Health
weight loss properties
hoodia delivers
genuine hoodia
source of hoodia
african weight loss
diet pills benefit
healthy diet
good diet plan
hoodia cactus plants
weight loss supplements
diet hoodia patch
hoodia gordonii weight loss pill
hoodia gordonii diet pill
hoodia 57
best diet hoodia pill
hoodia x57
hoodia gordonii cactus
hoodia diet supplement
hoodia pill
hoodia canada
buy hoodia
hoodia gordin
diet hoodia miracle
diet hoodia miracle
hoodia thin
hoodia loss patch weight
gnc hoodia
hoodia sucker
hoodia dex l10
hoodia testimonials
hoodia supplement
oodia hoodia
best diet hoodia
phytopharm hoodia
hoodia herb
911 hoodia
hoodia diet max
hoodia life
hoodia pur
hoodia weight loss pill
desert burn hoodia
effects hoodia plant side
diet hoodia pill that work
dex l10 hoodia gordonii
green tea and hoodia
hoodia research
hoodia comparison
hoodia plus pur
hoodia weight loss diet pill
hoodia gordonii extrac
african hoodia cactus
lose weight with hoodia
hoodia tea
ephedra hoodia
african hoodia south
hoodia 750
10 day diet hoodia
phentermine hoodia diet pill
hoodia review of pill
pure hoodia gordonii

play bingo
bingo sites
online bingo
bingo online
bingo casino
bingo casinos
internet bingo
bingo websites
bingo web sites
play bingo online

safety bingo
online bingo websites
online bingo software
benefits of playing bingo
bingo callers
bingo card
bingo game
bingo games for kids
bingo halls
bingo math
bingo millionaire
bingo party
bingo poems
bingo shutter cards
bingo slots
bingo supply
bingo tournaments
cash bingo
cyber bingo chat
cyber bingo players
flash bingo
free bingo games online
icebreaker bingo
internet bingo tips
online bingo bonus
online bingo etiquette
online bingo humour
online bingo pointers
online bingo portals
online bingo recognition
online bingo secrets
online bingo social benefits